Rent Discounts and N4's

Caselaw.Ninja, Riverview Group Publishing 2021 ©
Date Retrieved:	2024-06-17
CLNP Page ID:	1814
Page Categories:	[Payment of Rent (LTB)]
Citation:	Rent Discounts and N4's, CLNP 1814, <4t>, retrieved on 2024-06-17
Editor:	MKent
Last Updated:	2021/11/26

Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c. 17

111 (1) No landlord shall charge rent for a rental unit in an amount that is greater than the lawful rent permitted under this Part. 2006, c. 17, s. 111 (1).

(2) The lawful rent is not affected by a discount in rent at the beginning of, or during, a tenancy of up to 2 per cent of the rent that could otherwise be lawfully charged for a rental period if the discount is provided for paying rent on or before the date it is due and the discount meets the prescribed conditions. 2009, c. 33, Sched. 21, s. 11 (5).

(2.1) The lawful rent is not affected if one of the following discounts is provided:

1. A discount in rent at the beginning of, or during, a tenancy that consists of up to three months rent in any 12-month period if the discount is provided in the form of rent-free periods and meets the prescribed conditions.

2. A prescribed discount. 2009, c. 33, Sched. 21, s. 11 (5).

(2.2) For greater certainty, the lawful rent is not affected if discounts described in subsections (2) and (2.1) are both provided. 2009, c. 33, Sched. 21, s. 11 (5).

(3) Subject to subsections (2) and (2.1), where a landlord offers a discount in rent at the beginning of, or during, a tenancy, the lawful rent shall be calculated in accordance with the prescribed rules. 2006, c. 17, s. 111 (3); 2009, c. 33, Sched. 21, s. 11 (6).

O. Reg. 516/06: GENERAL

12. (1) The rules set out in this section apply in calculating lawful rent under subsection 111 (3) of the Act. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (1).

(2) The lawful rent for any rental period in the 12-month period shall be calculated in the following manner:

1. Add the sum of the rents that are actually charged or to be charged in each of the rental periods in the 12-month period to the largest eligible discount determined under subsection (6).

2. Divide the amount determined under paragraph 1 by the number of rental periods in the 12-month period.

3. Add to the amount determined under paragraph 2 any rent increases under section 123 of the Act and subtract from that amount any rent decreases under section 125 of the Act. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (2).

(3) Despite subsection (2), if a landlord provides a discount in rent that is greater than 2 per cent of the rent that could otherwise be lawfully charged for a rental period for paying rent on or before the date it is due, the lawful rent shall be calculated by dividing the discounted rent by 0.98. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (3); O. Reg. 377/11, s. 3 (1).

(4) Despite subsections (2) and (3), if the landlord provides a discount in rent described in subsection 111 (2) of the Act and another discount, other than a discount described in subsection 111 (2.1) of the Act, the lawful rent for any rental period in the 12-month period shall be calculated in the following manner:

1. Add the sum of the rents that are actually charged or to be charged in each of the rental periods in the 12-month period to the sum of the discounts described in subsection 111 (2) of the Act actually provided or to be provided to the tenant during the 12-month period.

2. Add the amount determined under paragraph 1 to the largest eligible discount determined under subsection (6).

3. Divide the amount determined under paragraph 2 by the number of rental periods in the 12-month period.

4. Add to the amount determined under paragraph 3 any rent increases under section 123 of the Act and subtract from that amount any rent decreases under section 125 of the Act. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (4); O. Reg. 256/10, s. 3 (1, 2).

(5) Despite subsections (2) and (3), if the landlord provides a discount in rent that is greater than 2 per cent of the rent that could otherwise be lawfully charged for a rental period for paying rent on or before the date it is due, and the landlord also provides another discount in rent, other than a discount described in subsection 111 (2.1) of the Act, the lawful rent for any rental period in the 12-month period shall be calculated in the following manner:

1. Divide the discounted rent by 0.98.

2. Multiply the amount determined under paragraph 1 by the number of rental periods in the 12-month period and add the result to the largest eligible discount determined under subsection (6).

3. Divide the amount determined under paragraph 2 by the number of rental periods in the 12-month period.

4. Add to the amount determined under paragraph 3 any rent increases under section 123 of the Act and subtract from that amount any rent decreases under section 125 of the Act. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (5); O. Reg. 256/10, s. 3 (3).

(6) For the purpose of this section, the largest eligible discount shall be determined in accordance with the following rules:

1. In the case of a discount that is provided for in a written agreement, the largest eligible discount is the largest of the following amounts:

i. The lesser of the following amounts:

A. The sum of the discounts in rent during the first eight months of the 12-month period.

B. The rent for one month.

ii. The largest discount in rent during any month in the last five months of the 12-month period, plus the lesser of the following amounts:

A. The sum of the discounts in rent during the first seven months of the 12-month period.

B. The rent for one month.

iii. The largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, if,

A. the rent is paid monthly, and

B. the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period is equal to the rent for less than one month.

iv. The sum of the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period and the second-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, if,

A. the rent is paid monthly,

B. the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period is equal to the rent for one month, and

C. the second-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period is equal to the rent for less than one month.

v. The sum of the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, the second-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, and the third-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, if,

A. the rent is paid monthly,

B. the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period and the second-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period are both equal to the rent for one month, and

C. the third-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period is equal to the rent for less than one month.

vi. The rent for three months, if,

A. the rent is paid monthly, and

B. the largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, the second-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period, and the third-largest discount in rent during any month in the 12-month period are all equal to the rent for one month.

vii. The lesser of the following amounts, if the rent is paid daily or weekly:

A. The sum of the discounts in rent provided in the form of rent-free weeks during the 12-month period.

B. The rent for 13 weeks.

2. In the case of a discount that is not provided for in a written agreement, the largest eligible discount is the largest discount in rent in one rental period in the 12-month period. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (6); O. Reg. 377/11, s. 3 (2).

(7) Despite subsection (2), if a tenancy agreement operates under the Strong Communities Housing Allowance Program — Toronto Pilot, and the landlord does not comply with paragraph 3 of subsection 11 (1), the lawful rent shall be the undiscounted rent that was permitted under the Act at the time when the tenancy agreement began to operate under the Program. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (7).

(8) In this section,

“the 12-month period” has the same meaning as in section 11. O. Reg. 516/06, s. 12 (8).

SOL-19029-11 (Re), 2011 CanLII 101417

Lawful Rent

3. The Landlord claimed the lawful monthly rent to be $700.00. He relies on the lease agreement which reads: When rent is paid by the first of the month it will be discounted from $700.00 to $675.00.

4. Subsection 111(2) of the Act provides:

The lawful rent is not affected by a discount in rent at the beginning of, or during, a tenancy of up to 2 per cent of the rent that could otherwise be lawfully charged for a rental period if the discount is provided for paying rent on or before the date it is due and the discount meets the prescribed conditions.

5. Subsection 111 (3) of the Act provides:

Subject to subsections (2) and (2.1), where a landlord offers a discount in rent at the beginning of, or during, a tenancy, the lawful rent shall be calculated in accordance with the prescribed rules.

6. The discount provided for from $700.00 to $675.00 is greater than 2 per cent. Therefore the lawful rent is affected by this discount.

7. Section 12 of O. Reg. 516/06 sets out the rules that apply in calculating lawful rent under Subsection 111(3) of the Act. This section is too long to reproduce here in its entirety.

8. The Landlord relies on Subsection 12(6) of O. Reg. 516\06. However, Subsection 12(6) does not apply to the type of discount provided for in the lease agreement. Subsection 12(6) is used to determine the largest possible discount, a concept which forms part of the calculation of the lawful rent pursuant to Subsections 12(2), 12(4), and 12(5). Subsections 12(4) and 12(5) do not apply in this situation as they set out rules to calculate the lawful rent in situations where both a discount under 111(2) of the Act, and another discount are provided to a tenant.

9. Subsection 12(2) does not apply in this situation as it is ruled out by Subsection 12(3), which provides:

Despite subsection (2), if a landlord provides a discount in rent that is greater than 2 per cent of the rent that could otherwise be lawfully charged for a rental period for paying rent on or before the date it is due, the lawful rent shall be calculated by dividing the discounted rent by 0.98

10. Accordingly, the lawful rent is determined by dividing the discounted rent ($675.00) by

0.98 (675 ⁄ 0.98 = 688.77). Therefore, the lawful monthly rent is $688.77.

N4 Notice to Terminate

11. The Landlord claimed the rent charged on the Notice to End a Tenancy Early for Non- payment of Rent (N4) to be $700.00. This is incorrect. Because of this the notice requires the Tenants to pay more than the lawful rent to void the notice. As a result the notice is invalid.

12. Without a valid N4 Notice the Board does not have the jurisdiction to order eviction for non-payment of rent. As a result, the order will be limited to rent arrears and costs only, not eviction.